Science behind why you don’t care about your future self

Hal Hershfield, a psychologist on the UCLA Anderson College of Administration, wished to know why individuals weren’t saving for retirement.

Throughout the board, individuals are dwelling longer. Logically, they’ll want extra money to stay comfortably of their post-work years. And but, financial savings charges within the US have gone down in current a long time, not up. The typical American inside 15 years of retirement age saves at solely one-third of the speed required to take care of their present way of life. Why do individuals spend at present on the expense of their future well-being?

To assist clarify this seemingly irrational habits, Hershfield and his staff scanned the brains of examine individuals whereas asking them to what diploma varied traits—like “honorable” or “humorous”—utilized to their present self, their future self, a present different, or a future different.


As individuals answered, Hershfield’s staff recorded which elements of their brains lit up.

Unsurprisingly, individuals’s brains had been most lively when considering about their present selves and least lively when considering about a present different. (People are typically a self-oriented bunch, in any case.) It was in evaluating these mind scans to these taken whereas considering about the Future Self the place issues bought fascinating.

Hershfield’s staff discovered that individuals’ mind exercise whereas contemplating their Future Selves extra intently resembled mind exercise whereas considering about a present different moderately than the present self.

Put in sensible phrases, when considering of your self in a month or a yr or a decade, your mind registers that particular person in methods much like how it could register Taylor Swift or the mailman or the woman driving the automotive within the subsequent lane over. Understood in that approach, saving for retirement is the neurological equal of giving cash away to another person totally. Performing in your personal self-interest (as your mind so narrowly defines it), it turns into completely logical to not save for retirement.

For the power procrastinators of the world (myself very a lot included), Hershfield’s findings are each comforting and horrifying. It’s definitive proof our tendency to place issues off isn’t an ethical failing however a neural one—our brains are wired to place our Current Selves first. (You could have my blessing to make use of that sentence on your boss the following time you miss a deadline.)

Alternatively, the issue of working towards long-term objectives feels extra insurmountable than ever. We’re not simply combating our willpower (or lack thereof), however our neurological wiring.

In gentle of Hershfield’s examine and others prefer it, I wished to reply one easy query: Is it doable to make our Current Selves give a rattling about our Future Selves? The solutions I discovered had been something however easy.


What’s Current Bias and the way does it influence our selections?

Current Bias describes individuals’s tendency to go for a smaller, speedy reward moderately than ready for a much bigger reward within the future. This cognitive bias explains a lot of our self-defeating actions—like selecting to observe Netflix moderately than go to the gymnasium, checking Twitter moderately than writing that article due tomorrow, or agreeing to tackle a future challenge that you have completely no time for as a result of it’s simpler to only say sure.

We get to benefit from the very concrete, speedy advantages of our actions whereas “another person” (our Future Selves) undergo the hypothetical, future penalties. Consequently, the choices we make for our Current Selves typically look very totally different from our selections for our Future Selves.

First, we are likely to overcommit our future time. A 2008 paper with the apt title “Do Unto Future Selves as You Would Do Unto Others” describes one examine through which undergraduate college students had been requested to commit their time to tutor struggling friends throughout mid-terms week, a very anxious time of yr.

One group of individuals was requested to decide to tutoring in the course of the present midterm interval (the Current Self situation); a second group was requested to decide to tutoring in the course of the subsequent midterm interval (the Future Self situation); and a 3rd group was requested how a lot time they thought new, incoming freshmen may spare to assist out (the Current Different situation).

The researchers discovered a big distinction in generosity between the current and the future. These requested how a lot time they might be keen to commit within the current stated simply 27 minutes on common whereas these requested to commit throughout the next midterm interval responded with a mean of 85 minutes. Much more compelling is the truth that the examine discovered no statistically vital distinction between the variety of minutes college students dedicated for his or her future selves and time dedicated for another person totally.

This example could sound acquainted. When was the final time you dedicated to taking up one thing new regardless of an already overloaded schedule? Possibly you had been motivated by the thrill of a brand new problem at work or the social stress to volunteer at your child’s college. Regardless of the case, implicit in your resolution was the idea that your Future Self’s capability and motivation would by some means be larger than these of your Current Self.

Then when it comes time to really do the factor we dedicated ourselves to, we as soon as once more prioritize our current consolation over future well-being. When considering of duties that should be completed, we frequently create narratives about how troublesome or painful or boring these duties can be.

We imagine that tomorrow can be totally different. We imagine that we’ll be totally different tomorrow; however in doing so, we prioritize our present temper over the results of our inaction for the future self.

— Procrastination and the Priority of Short-Term Mood Regulation: Consequences for Future Self

These destructive ideas create very actual psychological—and generally bodily—discomfort. We’ve willed stress, anxiousness, and worry of failure into existence. Within the course of, we create what writer Steven Pressfield has named Resistance (with a capital R).

When confronted with that Resistance, we detour. As Pressfield says in his e-book The Conflict of Artwork:

We don’t inform ourselves. “I’m by no means going to put in writing my symphony.” As a substitute we are saying, “I’m going to put in writing my symphony, I’m simply going to start out tomorrow.”

This means of giving in and laying aside is, at its core, a solution to self-medicate. By transferring the discomfort of the Current Self onto the summary and distant picture of our Future Self, we’re in a position to alleviate the stress of doing no matter it’s we don’t need to do. We really feel speedy reduction.


After all, the Future Self inevitably turns into the Current Self, and we’re left to cope with what we averted previously in addition to our emotions of disgrace, guilt, and fear. We overcommit after which procrastinate on our commitments. Then we punish ourselves for this procrastination, creating additional destructive emotions across the subsequent duties earlier than us. So begins the cycle of more and more destructive feelings and additional procrastination.

So how can we counteract Current Bias to realize our long-term objectives?

Understanding procrastination by the lens of Current Bias, we’re left with 3 doable options:

1. Drive your Future Self to do no matter it’s your Current Self doesn’t need to do.

Within the psychological warfare between your Current Self and your Future Self, your Current Self has a few key benefits.

First, you may be pretty assured that your Future Self will suppose and act in the identical actual approach that your Current Self thinks and acts. Which means you have full data of your Future Self’s weaknesses and may anticipate your Future Self’s actions and counteractions with fairly excessive accuracy.

(After all, this may require you to cease deluding your Current Self that your Future Self will by some means magically have all of the willpower and motivation on this planet to do no matter it’s your Current Self is laying aside. You gained’t. Assume the worst of your Future Self and you’ll be significantly better ready.)

Second, your Current Self can do any variety of issues to make your Future Self’s life simpler. Or more durable relying on how you have a look at it. And till time journey is invented, your Future Self can’t do a factor to cease you.

Make it straightforward for your Future Self to do no matter it’s your Current Self doesn’t need to do:

  • If you need to save extra money, arrange automated withdrawals from your checking account each month so your Future Self doesn’t have the money available to go blow it on no matter it’s your Future Self blows cash on.
  • If you need to eat more healthy, hold wholesome snacks inside arm’s attain always. Prep wholesome meals for the week on Sunday. Freeze wholesome meals to fall again on in emergencies.
  • If you need to get began on no matter huge challenge you’ve been laying aside, get all the things in place the evening earlier than. For instance, tomorrow morning I actually need to end writing this text, so earlier than I’m going to mattress I’m going to shut out all my different apps and put the doc in full-screen mode so it’s the primary and solely factor I see after I open my pc.

Clearly, these methods are usually not Future-You-Proof. I can, and have, instantly minimized my full-screen doc within the morning in favor of catching up on Twitter. That’s why it’s useful to maintain some deterrence techniques in your arsenal as nicely.

Make it as inconvenient as doable for your Future Self to do the issues your Current Self needs to do:

  • If you typically sit down at your pc to make progress on a challenge, solely to seek out your self on Fb or Reddit moments later, set up apps like Freedom to dam—or at the very least restrict your time on—probably the most distracting websites.
  • If you need to begin your day with a exercise however have a tough time really getting your self off the bed, use a type of sadistic alarm clock apps that makes you do math issues or stand up and scan a barcode far-off from the tempting consolation of your mattress.
  • If you need to save extra money however fall prey to internet advertising, unsubscribe from any promo electronic mail lists that you discover tempting and block the websites you like to purchase from.

To this point we’ve talked about issues that nudge your Future Self towards the suitable path and away from the incorrect one, however generally extra drastic measures are wanted—one thing that actually forces your Future Self to cease avoiding and get to work. Some individuals name these “Dedication Gadgets.” I like to think about them as “Future Self Torture Gadgets.” Pot-a-to, pot-ah-to.

Listed here are two of the best methods to make your Future Self’s life depressing (your Future Future Self will thank you):

  • Nothing will get your Future Self shifting like a very good old style deadline. When circumstances don’t create them for you, you should create them your self — ideally hooked up to some unsavory penalties if you don’t meet them.
  • Get an accountabilibuddy, be part of a category, or rent a coach — the sunk value mixed with social stress to observe by could make it onerous to justify not exhibiting up even when you don’t really feel prefer it.

The particular techniques you use to set your Future Self up for higher selections will depend upon your distinctive objectives. The vital factor is to keep in mind that your Future Self goes to do all the things in her energy to not do no matter it’s that you need her to do, so you’ll should be each inventive and ruthless.

2. Persuade your Current Self that your Future Self is, in reality, nonetheless You.

If the central downside is that we consider our Future Selves as different individuals — individuals we clearly don’t thoughts screwing over — it follows that making an attempt to determine extra intently with our Future Selves will encourage us to make higher long-term selections.

In a follow-up to his 2009 neuroimaging examine, Hershfield wished to discover methods to bridge the disconnect between the current and future selves and encourage individuals to save lots of extra for retirement. He and his staff took pictures of examine individuals, then used picture processing to visually age their faces. Contributors had been then positioned in a digital actuality setting the place they may look right into a mirror and see their aged selves wanting again at them. Contributors who noticed their aged selves stated they might save 30% extra of their wage for retirement than the management group.

You’ll be able to really replicate Hershfield’s experimental situations utilizing a (mildly terrifying) app known as Aging Booth, however there are a lot simpler options to make your Future Self really feel extra like, nicely, you.

Within the tutoring examine described in an earlier part, a fourth experimental group was additionally requested to commit their Future Selves to tutor throughout the next midterms interval. Nonetheless, this group was explicitly reminded that in the course of the subsequent midterms they might possible have the identical workload, expertise the identical pressures, and in any other case be the identical particular person they’re proper now. College students who obtained the reminder dedicated their Future Selves to considerably fewer minutes of tutoring (a mean of 45 minutes) than those that didn’t obtain the reminder (a mean of 85 minutes).

The outcomes recommend that merely taking a second to keep in mind that your Future Self is, in reality, nonetheless you, will help you make higher long-term selections.

One solution to extra vividly step into the sneakers of your Future Self, so to talk, is to put in writing a letter to or from your Future Self. A study printed earlier this yr by Hershfield together with a number of collaborators discovered that individuals who wrote a letter to themselves 20 years into the future had been extra more likely to train within the following days in comparison with a gaggle who wrote to themselves simply 3 months into the future.

One other tactic to bridge the divide between your Current and Future Selves is to make the future appear nearer. A study carried out by researchers on the College of Michigan and the College of Southern California discovered that when individuals suppose about future occasions by way of days moderately than years, the occasions really feel like they’re taking place sooner. Moreover, when individuals had been requested to think about a far-off occasion like retirement, those that had been instructed it was taking place in 10,950 days began saving 4 occasions earlier than those that had been instructed it could occur in 30 years.

No matter your long-term objectives could also be — getting in higher form, launching your personal enterprise, writing a e-book — considering about your deadline by way of days moderately than months or years will help you wrap your thoughts round how shut the future actually is.

Tim City, author and founding father of the ever-entertaining weblog Wait However Why, took this idea a step additional, devising a easy but extremely efficient solution to visualize simply how finite life may be. In an article titled Your Life in Weeks, City lays out a 90-year life in a grid with every row representing a yr and every block representing one week. (You should purchase a 24″ by 36″ poster model on his website for $20.) He encourages his readers to make use of their life grids as a software for self-reflection and objective setting: What have you achieved with your weeks thus far? What do you need to accomplish with them within the future?

“Each the week chart above and the life calendar are a reminder to me that this grid of empty bins staring me within the face is mine. We are likely to really feel locked into no matter life we’re dwelling, however this pallet of empty bins may be completely no matter we would like it to be. Everybody you know, everybody you admire, each hero in historical past — they did all of it with that very same grid of empty bins.”

The following time you end up procrastinating on a specific objective or making a choice with far-off penalties, take a second to get in contact with your Future Self:

  • Write a letter from a distant Future Self—think about what your life can be like and what issues can be vital to you.
  • Set a deadline for your objective by way of days, weeks, and even hours, moderately than months or years.
  • Visualize that deadline within the type of a “objective grid” with every field representing a day. Circle bins for sure milestones you need to hit alongside the way in which. Write what you accomplish day-to-day and verify the bins off as you go.
  • Initially of daily, think about your self utterly glad on the finish of the day. What one factor have you achieved? Begin on that process first.

We are likely to suppose we’ll get pleasure from infinite time and alternative within the future, however on the geologic scale of time, our lives are barely a blink. Discovering methods to remind ourselves of how little really separates our Current and Future Selves could assist align at present’s actions with tomorrow’s objectives.

3. Neglect about your Future Self and use your Current Self’s love of on the spot gratification to your benefit.

Whereas the 2 techniques above may be efficient in making higher long-term selections, ultimately, you’re nonetheless struggling in opposition to human nature. Our brains are hard-wired for fast gratification. As a substitute of combating your Current Self’s want for speedy rewards, why not use it to your benefit?

When most of us set objectives, we give attention to long-term outcomes we need to see — e.g., reducing weight, getting a promotion, retiring in consolation, mastering your craft, and many others. Whereas these visions of our Future Selves may be inspiring, in the case of really doing the day-to-day work it could be more practical to reframe actions by way of their speedy (or at the very least very near-term) rewards.

Take writing this text, as an example. It’s straightforward for me to think about how superb it should really feel on the finish of the workday to have this text completed and off my to-do checklist for good.

Be aware that I didn’t say how superb it should really feel when the article is printed to the fanfare of 1000’s of adoring followers and I’m provided a e-book deal and I flip it right into a New York Instances bestselling masterpiece and go on a first-class world tour to advertise, and many others, and many others. As a substitute, I’m going to give attention to the sense of accomplishment I’ll really feel in simply 4 hours time when I’ll now not should really feel responsible about not ending this factor I’ve delay for thus lengthy that it’s began to really feel like a squirmy eel within the pit of my abdomen each time I feel about it.

(I notice that 4 hours from now is just not precisely on the spot gratification within the strictest sense, nevertheless it’s a complete lot simpler to care about 4 Hours From Now Becky than 4 Years From Now Becky.)

This isn’t simply me speaking anecdotally. Analysis companions Kaitlin Woolley of Cornell College and Ayelet Fishbach of the College of Chicago, have made a profession out of studying the variations between the objectives that folks obtain and those that fall to the wayside:

“In a single examine, we requested individuals on-line about the objectives they set in the beginning of the yr. Most individuals set objectives to realize delayed, long-term advantages, similar to profession development, debt reimbursement, or improved well being. We requested these people how pleasurable it was to pursue their objective, in addition to how vital their objective was. We additionally requested whether or not they had been nonetheless engaged on their objectives two months after setting them. We discovered that enjoyment predicted individuals’s objective persistence two months after setting the objective way over how vital they rated their objective to be.”

This sample held true throughout all kinds of objectives from exercising to learning to consuming more healthy meals. For instance, individuals ate 50% extra of wholesome meals when directed to give attention to the nice style moderately than the long-term well being advantages.

These findings recommend that in the case of reaching your objectives, having fun with the method itself is extra vital than wanting the long-term advantages. In different phrases, Current Self trumps Future Self.

In relation to engaging in objectives, having fun with the method is extra vital than wanting the long-term advantages.

You should utilize this reality to encourage your Current Self to do (or not do) a stunning variety of issues:

  • As a substitute of exercising for the bikini bod you need 6 months from now (and even the decreased probabilities of dying), select a kind of exercise that you really get pleasure from and give attention to the speedy increase in temper and stress reduction you get from it.
  • As a substitute of learning onerous to get good grades, select topics you get pleasure from studying about and give attention to the satisfaction you get from the educational course of itself.
  • As a substitute of sending out a bunch of chilly emails to hit your annual, and even month-to-month, sales goals, give attention to how good it should really feel to close your pc and go away work on the finish of the day freed from the guilt that you ought to have completed extra. And even gamify your productiveness with the paper clip strategy.

And when you do should do unavoidably boring and unsightly duties, attempt to bundle them with issues you get pleasure from — like going to your favourite espresso store, listening to your favourite podcast, or consuming your favourite snack.

Who says on the spot gratification needs to be a foul factor? By all means, set bold long-term objectives for your Future Self, however in the case of really following by day-to-day, be sure your Current Self is aware of what’s in it for her too.

Homework for Current You

Now that you’ve procrastinated from doing no matter it’s you had been speculated to be doing by studying this text, it’s time to really put these insights into motion:

  • What one objective can be most vital to you in 20 years? If it’s useful to you, write a letter from your Future Self. Write down your objective someplace you’ll see it daily. If you’re a Todoist person, create a new project for your objective and favorite it so it exhibits up on the high of your checklist.
  • Record out the concrete actions that you’ll should do to achieve that objective. For instance, if the objective is to put in writing a e-book, you may need to set a particular every day phrase rely you need to attain. Add that process or duties to your challenge. Give every one a due date if you’ll solely must do it as soon as or a recurring due date if it’s one thing you’ll must do every day or weekly.
  • Now, checklist out all the issues that your Current Self will need to do as a substitute of reaching that phrase rely. Occurring Fb, doing the laundry, answering electronic mail, and many others. For every merchandise on this checklist, give you a method that may make it more durable e.g., block (or higher but, stop) Fb, work from a coworking house or espresso store, block out particular time later within the day to reply all your emails.
  • Subsequent, checklist out any and all techniques you can consider to both automate these actions or make it as straightforward as doable to get began on them very first thing within the morning. Begin constructing these techniques into your end-of-the-workday routine. Add them as recurring duties — e.g., “each weekday at 5 pm” — in your Todoist so you don’t neglect to do them.
  • Decide to a deadline for your objective — the extra public and binding the dedication the higher. Ask your self how you can set a deadline in a approach that may have actual penalties if you don’t meet it?
  • Calculate the variety of workdays — and even work hours — you have till your deadline. Daring and underline this quantity. Write it on a post-it word and stick it someplace you’ll see on a regular basis and replace the quantity often. Or visualize it in a grid with every field representing a day or hour till you have to achieve your objective. Tick off the bins as you go.
  • Lastly, checklist out all the speedy rewards you’ll get from the day-to-day actions you’ll must take to achieve your long-term objective. Are there methods to make these actions extra pleasurable in and of themselves? Deal with having fun with the method moderately than the long-term advantages.

I’m sorry I couldn’t present a straightforward reply to our procrastination downside. Our selections about how one can spend our time, what we eat, how a lot we train, the place we spend our cash are advanced. We gained’t ever do the “proper factor” 100% of the time. However understanding our current bias on the expense of the future will help us begin bridging the hole between who we’re and who we need to turn out to be.

This article initially appeared on Doist and is reprinted with permission.


7 Cognitive biases that make us suck at time management

How context switching sabotages your productivity

How to craft the perfect daily schedule