Inside the high-stakes world of designing for 911

inline paper layout

Anita Pitt sits at her desk, the place she speaks with a melodious Texas drawl. She doesn’t convey any explicit sense of urgency, and but, over the previous 37 years as program supervisor of Brazos County 911, her complete job has been about conveying urgency. She manages the employees and expertise in her area as a small however very important half of the community of 6,100 emergency name facilities scattered throughout the United States. These name facilities discipline 200 million calls a yr.

“I believe rather a lot of folks’s notion of 911 is what they see on TV,” she says, alluding to glitzy, techie procedurals equivalent to CSI, the place dispatchers seem to work in mission management. “Whereas in rural Texas, that’s not at all times the case. There are rather a lot of locations round the nation which can be barely holding their heads above water with expertise.”

911 operator-dispatchers have one of the hardest, most thankless jobs in the world. It takes six months of on-the-job coaching to grow to be dispatchers. That’s as a result of they’ve to select up a cellphone and discuss to somebody in the center of critical trauma—each soothing them and extracting crucial info—whereas coordinating one or a number of police, hearth, and well being departments to reach on the scene ASAP. Alongside the method, an operator could also be utilizing half a dozen items of unrelated software program throughout three to 6 laptop screens, utilizing a number of keyboards, mice, and even foot pedals, whereas concurrently manning a radio to hook up with assistance on the floor.

“You actually don’t know what form of name you get, so we have now to be ready for something,” says Kristi Stamnes, director of Washington County 9-1-1, who works beneath Pitt. “Nobody ever calls us on their good days.”


That is the high-stakes world of a 911 name heart, a design downside like no different. “It’s an space of our society that’s been vastly underserved by design for its complete existence,” says Lexie Spiro, former director of consumer expertise and analysis at Motorola Options (who just lately left for Amazon). Motorola Options is the market chief in each radios and emergency software program for public security.

At Motorola, Spiro was half of a small however extremely specialised group of designers that focuses on the split-second UX of first response. The corporate’s software program consolidates disparate 911 packages right into a single, easy-to-navigate platform. This has earned Motorola greater than 3,500 prospects for its emergency software program—together with a $120 million 911 shopper the firm signed final yr, the largest contract in its historical past. Between March and June of final yr, COVID-19 more than doubled 911 wait occasions, from 9 seconds to 25 seconds—with a number of reviews of folks being on maintain for minutes earlier than reaching a dispatcher as places reached capability. The necessity has by no means been extra urgent—however the actuality is that it’s a a lot larger downside than software program alone can repair.

Expectations versus actuality

A well-functioning 911 system is essential for public security, however there are few industries with as massive a gulf between what the public expects is going on versus what is actually taking place.

911 name facilities are up in opposition to all types of challenges, which impede their effectivity and functionality. They purchase software program from a number of distributors, which doesn’t essentially combine nicely. Moreover, most dispatchers have restricted funding to improve to the newest applied sciences and will be caught for as much as a decade utilizing older tech. Turnover is fast in the high-stress, low-paid business, so new staff are always being educated in workplaces which can be notoriously understaffed. And whereas outdated, inefficient software program is problematic for dispatchers, there’s additionally a pure pressure round introducing any change—with its personal studying curve—when seconds really matter. Think about how infuriating it may be when your favourite app strikes a button to a extra esoteric spot. Nicely, know that the stress of liking a publish on social media is decrease than a home hearth.

Individuals don’t understand all this once they name in. We count on that 911 is usually extra succesful than it’s, and we will see that with a expertise so simple as location monitoring. Which is why one of the first questions of each 911 name is the place you’re positioned.

“911 as an business must attempt to meet the expectations of residents,” says Pitt. “They suppose they will discover us on a wi-fi name, that we robotically know exactly the place they’re. That’s simply not true!”

I used to be as stunned as anybody to be taught that while you name emergency companies, they can’t at all times merely see the excellent GPS location out of your cellphone. As an alternative, your cellphone provider will usually generalize your location to a cell tower, which could possibly be miles away. (And so dispatchers should usually double as investigators, each confirming and narrowing down the place an individual is.)


This issue is beginning to change, nonetheless. As Pitt explains, six months in the past her county upgraded to RapidSOS, which is a platform that may take benefit of extra sensors in a caller’s cellphone to additional triangulate location by way of additional connections equivalent to Bluetooth and Wi-Fi. The Federal Communications Fee can also be investing in a brand new commonplace that can be capable to observe the altitude of somebody’s cellphone, which means they might extra simply be noticed in high-rise buildings. However that was delayed with COVID-19 as a result of the issue of sending technicians to check so many areas.

“Individuals don’t know the place they’re. They haven’t any clue,” says Pitt. “We’re a society that, we will hit the automobile and go, and we don’t take note of landmarks and issues. That could be very irritating for the name taker.”

As soon as a dispatcher has the handle, that knowledge will be despatched electronically, together with different notes, to the first responder on the floor. At the identical time, dispatchers will hop between the cellphone and a radio, checking in with the caller and the responder, and double-checking that nothing is misplaced in translation.

So how will we repair this?

Clearly there’s an academic element for the public that would mitigate our expectations for 911 versus the actuality of the service. However what will be accomplished to make the jobs of operators extra manageable?

“This piece of the business is, frankly, wanting like the tech business in the early ’90s,” says Matthew Sinclair, SVP of software program at Motorola Options. “You’re shopping for Phrase from right here, Excel from there, and making an attempt to cobble all of it collectively.”

There aren’t any shortages of corporations constructing 911 software program, together with Omnigo, CentralSquare, Hexagon, and DataTech 911. A lot of Motorola’s promise in the business is to offer a extra streamlined expertise for name takers, rolling up so many disparate apps right into a extra singular, cloud-based platform referred to as CommandCentral, which Sinclair positions as one thing like Microsoft’s Workplace 365, however for emergencies.

The system has some useful applied sciences. Motorola can now use AI to real-time transcribe calls for a dispatcher and generally even pull up native digital camera feeds from the website of an accident, which helps the dispatcher examine the scenario and supply extra info to responders. However the greatest benefit could merely be that of workflow, which optimizes the method dispatchers look from one display to a different for info.

Optimizing such chaotic, legacy laptop programs is not any small feat. One of the greatest challenges of designing for a 911 heart is that it’s fairly troublesome to check somebody who’s working in an emergency scenario with out disrupting them. Whereas the employee hops between numerous screens, it may be laborious to parse why.

“We will’t simply interrupt a 911 name taker and ask, ‘Why did you say what you simply stated?’ We’d love contextual inquiry, seated subsequent to a name taker, observing their conduct . . . and we’re capable of ask questions in context about what they’re doing,” says Spiro, former director of consumer expertise and analysis at Motorola Options. “However the actuality is you may’t do this in a name heart! They’re on an necessary name!”

Motorola designers take part in job shadowing and eavesdrop on calls. They’ve seen dispatchers conduct CPR over the cellphone and attain for Publish-its to take down info to maneuver it between screens as a result of you may’t copy and paste between two computer systems. Moments like these can present a holistic view of the design challenges. However in terms of eliminating inefficiencies in the system, or determining how a specific state of affairs could possibly be simplified, that will get laborious.

“The factor to notice right here is it’s not that anyone of these merchandise is poorly designed,” says Spiro. “It’s that nobody has ever checked out what the total UX is for utilizing all of them without delay.”


To get an understanding of workflow throughout as much as 14 totally different apps on as many as seven screens, Motorola used eye-tracking programs. In any given class of emergency, a dispatcher seems at totally different screens in numerous orders. Motorola reveals me pictures of how they started with uncooked eye-tracking knowledge throughout 4 screens however then acknowledged patterns. These patterns are predictable display sequences.

I see how a housebreaking 911 dial leads folks to look from a name display, to a dispatch display for three steps, and again to a name display. They by no means take a look at the map, maybe as a result of folks on this scenario can identify their actual handle precisely. However an unintended dial is completely totally different. They start at the name display however ping-pong backwards and forwards between dispatching and the map. I’m taking a look at easy quantity sequences, however I can already see the narrative shaping up in my mind. Whereas the caller made an error, the operator continues to be skeptical, and referencing all out there info to make sure this particular person is actually as protected as they are saying they’re.

As soon as Motorola understood these workflows, they thought-about a brand new form of interface. As an alternative of giving an operator all knowledge all the time, what in the event that they prioritized it higher by state of affairs? They really handed off-the-clock dispatchers a collection of playing cards with totally different items of knowledge on them and tasked them with designing their very own splendid screens. The catch was that, by design, these playing cards couldn’t all match onto one display. They have been forcing dispatchers to prioritize info by state of affairs, which additional confirmed and superior findings from eye monitoring.

All of it added as much as grow to be a extra pure directional workflow, in response to Motorola. Whereas dispatchers beforehand darted their eyes in each route, like a fly exploring a room at random, Motorola designed a case to work its method from left to proper. A name is available in on the left, and it’s assigned a card with its predominant info. Because it’s dispatched, the card strikes to the center. And because it’s accomplished, it strikes to the proper. This retains pertinent knowledge flowing like a practice, relatively than scatted round all over the place.

As for the capabilities described to me by Matthew Sinclair, SVP of software program at Motorola Options, they don’t sound so removed from an episode of CSI in any respect. However all of that seamless integration requires extra buy-in to the Motorola platform—each figuratively and actually. Funding for 911 varies vastly by state, and as a result of some extraordinarily esoteric insurance policies, funding for the business has stayed stagnant and even dropped as operational prices have risen over time. It’s a purpose that the firm actually assists shoppers in looking for authorities grants.

“Come September first of this yr, I’ve to resolve, can I solely afford it for our county or our area. It’s laborious for me. Each 911 name is as necessary as the subsequent,” says Pitt. “That’s what retains me awake at night time. It’s not the calls. It’s the funding. I wish to present the identical companies for all our counties.”