Facebook is now Meta, but its ads are as empty as ever

As you’ll have heard final week, Facebook modified its identify to Meta. Now it’s launched the primary model marketing campaign underneath this new banner. A gaggle of 4 college students collect round Henri Rousseau’s 1908 portray Battle between a Tiger and a Buffalo. As they stare into its tropical colours, lush jungle, and paused violent motion, the portray comes alive.

We zoom into the canvas. What was as soon as 2D is now throughout us. The tiger appears to be like up and says, “this is the dimension of creativeness.” We flip and flop round, assembly toucans, flamingos, and what seem like raccoons with human noses, all dancing to “Means in My Mind” by SL2. As they’re sucked into the portray, the scholars’ faces go from skepticism to acceptance, heads bopping, hypnotized by the beat. Entranced. It ends with the Tiger and Buffalo now not combating, simply vibing. Meta.

Meta’s world director of name advertising and marketing Jasmine Summerset-Karcie told AdAge that the aim of the spot (created with company Droga5) is to share the imaginative and prescient of the corporate and “actually excite individuals in regards to the prospects of the metaverse.”


What does all of it imply? Not in a double rainbow kind of means, but actually, what the holy hell is this precisely speculated to imply? So the promise of the metaverse lies within the multidimensional freedom of strolling into an early twentieth Century avant-garde portray for a dance get together? And Meta is meant to represent that promise?

The fact is that Meta is only one firm engaged on the technological challenges of the purported metaverse, and even then, dancing round a Rousseau with your mates is nonetheless an extended, good distance off. Which signifies that this advert is a classy but empty distraction that claims completely nothing in regards to the model, the metaverse, or the imaginative and prescient of the corporate previously recognized as Facebook.

Again in 2012, plain ole Facebook launched its first main advertising and marketing push, timed to coincide with the ballyhooed billion-user milestone. That advert in contrast the social-media platform to a chair. Actually! My colleague Joe Berkowitz described it on the time as “stunning to take a look at, but it suffers from concurrently overreaching and oversimplifying.” Sounds eerily acquainted.

Facebook’s promoting has at all times been a bit defensive. In 2018, the corporate tried the earnest apology route with its “Right here Collectively” spot, that was maybe the closest it has ever come to saying sorry, whereas nonetheless portray itself as a sufferer. Nonetheless, it boldly stated, “from now on, Facebook will do extra to maintain you secure and shield your privateness, so we are able to all get again to what made Facebook nice within the first place.” That was three years in the past.

Final 12 months the model launched a tear-jerker advert celebrating a beloved New York neighborhood restaurant referred to as Coogan’s that was compelled to close down through the pandemic. It’s a stunning tribute to a uniquely particular small enterprise, till you keep in mind that Facebook is the place the place, in response to advocacy group Avaaz, deceptive well being content material had garnered an estimated 3.8 billion views over the previous 12 months.

A lot has occurred since then. So neglect apologies or decisive motion: “The Tiger & The Buffalo” is about misdirection. Neglect in regards to the revelations in The Wall Avenue Journal’s Facebook Files. Or the testimony of whistleblower Frances Haugen. Or the new study that claims local weather change denial is spreading unchecked on Facebook. Hey, look over right here! Take a look at these funky flamingos!

After the Meta rebrand announcement, Charlie Warzel wrote in his Galaxy Mind e-newsletter, “it reads to me like a declaration that the corporate can and can act with impunity. Right here’s an organization marching ahead and optimistically into the long run and ignoring the smoldering mess it made within the background.”


When Rousseau painted Battle between a Tiger and a Buffalo, he was in jail for fraud. He’d by no means truly seen a tiger, or a buffalo, or a jungle. According to the description on the Cleveland Museum of Artwork the place the portray hangs, it was a “improbable jungle atmosphere wherein botanical accuracy was of little significance.”

For Meta, its new advert conjures its personal improbable jungle atmosphere—and an analogous dedication to accuracy.