Designing cities to prevent suicide

On July 29, a 14-year-old boy jumped to his demise from the Vessel, the extravagant set up on the coronary heart of Hudson Yards in Manhattan.

That is the fourth suicide that has occurred there because the pseudo-public area, with its labyrinthine stairs to nowhere, opened to the general public in March 2019. Remarkably, it’s also the second time that the Vessel has closed due to a suicide: After the third demise in January 2021, new security measures had been put in place, together with elevated safety, a buddy system, and indicators with psychological well being assets. It took solely two months for these mitigation strategies to show ineffective.

[Photo: Kena Betancur/VIEWpress/Getty Images]

What occurred on the Vessel—which was dreamed up by British designer Thomas Heatherwick and developed by Associated, billionaire Stephen Ross’s actual property agency—is devastating, however not sudden. Earlier than the Vessel first closed, residents and critics had raised issues that its waist-high limitations might pose dangers, compounded by the unobstructed 150-foot-high drop to the bottom that the tapering construction gives.

“The group exhaustively explored bodily options that might enhance security,” Heatherwick Studio mentioned in an announcement, noting that these options wanted “additional rigorous assessments.” Reportedly, Heatherwick had designed larger security limitations that Associated by no means put in—though it’s unclear if that was earlier than or after the primary suicides happened. (In a quick assertion, a spokeswoman for Associated mentioned they had been “heartbroken” by the latest suicide and reiterated that the Vessel is presently closed.)


Whereas it’s unclear why Heatherwick’s limitations weren’t applied, it’s laborious not to speculate. With a whopping $200 million price ticket, the Vessel was publicized as New York Metropolis’s latest landmark. Described on Associated’s website as a “vertical climbing expertise” with “a few of the most unusual views of the West Facet,” it was meant as a public decoration, a “present” to the town. Presumably elevating the peak of the glass limitations, regardless of their transparency, might have spoiled the expertise.

However the fact is that the 4 deaths could effectively have been prevented with out compromising on the Vessel’s design. In reality, design will be a part of the answer to prevent suicides in public areas. Based mostly on previous examples, suicide prevention needn’t be an eyesore. It may be performed in a manner that’s useful, elegant, and doesn’t instill worry. It will probably even improve the general aesthetic expertise.

Whereas some studies present that elevating limitations merely redirects suicidal folks elsewhere, placing up obstacles has additionally been proven to save extra lives, significantly amongst kids and younger adults, who have a tendency to act on impulse. The 4 individuals who died by leaping from the Vessel had been 14, 19, 21, and 24 years outdated. In reality, suicide is the second leading cause of demise for kids, youngsters, and younger adults ages 15 to 24.

In her doctoral thesis on suicidal conditions in out of doors public locations, researcher Charlotta Thodelius observed that suicidal ideas amongst younger persons are typically impulsive and preventable. In western Sweden, the place she performed her analysis whereas on the Chalmers College of Know-how, suicide “sizzling spots” like bridges, prepare stations, and excessive buildings had been typically straightforward to entry or empty, with a low diploma of visibility. “This makes it doable to prevent suicides or suicidal conditions by a well-thought-out design,” she says. “I feel we are able to work with place and structure in the identical manner that society has labored to restrict entry to deadly merchandise to prevent suicides.”

Thodelius explains that suicide in public locations many instances follows what is known as a “suicidal script,” during which “suicidal individuals typically have a imaginative and prescient of the place they are going to commit suicide.” She notes that each area has a “native sizzling spot.” Within the south of England, it’s the precipitous cliffs at Beachy Head. In San Francisco, it’s the Golden Gate Bridge.

Help struts for an under-construction, anti-jump web at San Francisco’s Golden Gate Bridge [Photo: Justin Sullivan/Getty Images]

For the reason that Golden Gate Bridge was in-built 1937, about 1,700 folks have leapt to their deaths (though this determine is probably going larger since not all our bodies are recovered and never all victims are witnessed). The development of a suicide deterrent web started in 2019; after main delays, it’s now slated for completion in 2023.

In accordance to the nonprofit Bridge Rail Basis, which advocates for suicide prevention in public areas, the common age of people that bounce from the Golden Gate Bridge is below 40, and of the few who’ve jumped and survived, many reportedly didn’t have a backup plan for killing themselves. Thodelius’s analysis, whereas not referencing the bridge immediately, appears to affirm this: “If the entry to a sure place is restricted, they hardly ever swap location,” she says. 


This level has been a lot debated amongst researchers, however there does appear to be a consensus that restricted entry is almost definitely to deter youthful populations. Thodelius says it’s essential to discover methods to design obstacles with out instilling worry or adverse feelings. “Typically, after we talk about prevention and safety, we predict it wants to be a harsh design resembling tough metal fences,” she says. “Probably the most tough process is to maintain the bizarre features of locations for on a regular basis actions undisrupted whereas on the identical time stopping suicidal conditions.”

Bloor Viaduct, Toronto [Photo: Roberto Machado Noa/LightRocket/Getty Images]

When it comes to bridges, nets and tall fences are widespread deterrents, however in 2003, the town of Toronto took a extra artistic method on the Bloor Viaduct. As soon as the second-most-frequented bridge for suicides in North America (after the Golden Gate), the Bloor Viaduct counted a median of 9 deaths a 12 months earlier than the town commissioned the Luminous Veil—a seemingly kinetic steel barrier manufactured from skinny, metal rods that mild up at night time in a manner that adjustments each day in accordance to the season, temperature, and path of the wind.

For the reason that barrier went up 11 years in the past, just one particular person has died by suicide on the bridge. And whereas it’s not completely clear whether or not this dissuaded folks completely, a recent study means that suicide charges throughout the town have certainly dropped because the barrier was erected.

As it’s with deeply entrenched points surrounding psychological well being, there are two frameworks to take into account when coping with suicide prevention: Within the quick time period, tangible mitigation strategies like nets and limitations might help save lives; in the long run, the constructed setting will be rethought extra broadly to assist enhance psychological well being. In Manhattan, New York College’s Bobst Library gives a hanging instance of a comparatively short-term answer that mixes artistic considering with efficient suicide prevention.

Lower than two miles from the Vessel, the library’s previously open atrium had attracted two college students who jumped to their demise in 2003. And regardless of the 8-foot-tall plexiglass barrier that was put in afterward, one other pupil managed to clamber over and bounce in 2009.

The Pixel Veil at NYU’s Bobst Library [Photo: Jonny McHugh/Getty Images]

The answer got here in 2012, within the form of the Bobst Pixel Veil—a floor-to-ceiling, laser-cut display screen that encloses the skylit atrium with an nearly ethereal, intricately perforated bronze membrane glinting within the daylight.

Some critics have referred to as for the dismantling of the Vessel, but when it had been to stay, Heatherwick might little doubt provide you with a equally hanging mitigation method (supplied Associated agrees). However what concerning the longer-term plan of action?

“In the long term, we’d like to discover methods to embrace psychological well being within the design of the locations and areas that encompass us,” says Kevin Bennett, a instructing professor of psychology at Penn State Beaver and a fellow on the Centre for City Design and Psychological Well being in London.

“Folks all over the world, particularly in city environments, are feeling more and more remoted and disconnected,” Bennett says. He believes that locations must be constructed that gradual the event of melancholy, anxiousness, and different psychological sicknesses by designing for face-to-face interactions and elevated mobility.

For Bennett, the foundation of the issue with the Vessel is that it’s not an inclusive work of structure, and it doesn’t serve a perform that’s helpful to residents. “Heatherwick’s Vessel features principally as an artwork set up that just some able-bodied customers can use as stair-stepping train tools,” he says. “If we are able to construct higher locations, we are able to cut back the charges of suicide, not by eliminating bridges and different tall buildings, however by creating locations that promote power happiness and well-being.”

In the event you or somebody is in disaster, name the National Suicide Prevention Lifeline at 1-800-273-8255, textual content TALK to 741741, or go to for a listing of assets.