Apple’s 2021 MacBook Pro is the 2008 MacBook Pro

I work on daily basis on a $2,600 MacBook Pro. And the truth of the matter is that I like this MacBook lower than I appreciated any of my earlier MacBooks, all the manner again to my first one in 2005.

That’s as a result of, starting in 2016, Apple killed a few of its most beloved options in its MacBooks—options that went again a decade or longer. However with in the present day’s bulletins of recent 14- and 16-inch MacBook Execs, what’s previous is new once more. Apple has rewound Pro’s industrial design to its 2015 (and earlier) designs.

It might be straightforward to concentrate on Apple’s about-face as hypocritical or backtracking. However the fact is that Apple made a tough determination right here: It threw out a number of newer concepts to prioritize what I’d argue is timeless UX.

Table of Contents



Let’s start with the assassination of the Magsafe energy connector. Nobody complained about the Magsafe because it was first debuted in 2006. It solved an necessary drawback: For those who tripped over your laptop computer’s wire, your laptop computer would keep put in your desk, slightly than fly onto the floor. As an added bonus, Magsafe made it simpler to plug in your laptop computer. The previous Macbook Pro truly sucked the wire out of your hand, and positioned it completely in the charging port.

[Photo: Apple]

In 2016, Apple swapped Magsafe for a USB-C port to hold the energy. On paper, this may need appeared like a smart move. Magsafe was patented and proprietary. In the meantime, USB-C was common. In idea, the USB-C MacBook Pro could possibly be supported by a complete ecosystem of charging cables and batteries. And whereas that proved true, Magsafe is a hands-in-ears superior method to charging. USB-C can pull your laptop computer off a desk. USB-C requires you to line the plug up and jam it in with the correct quantity of pressure. Merely put: each single time I plug in my MacBook feels worse than it used to, so it’s nice to see Magsafe again in additional than simply iPhones.

The keyboard

Apple has been below fireplace since 2015 when it phased out its traditional scissors-switch keyboard for its butterfly keyboard design. These variations aren’t a lot to be seen; they confer with the particular mechanisms that enable your keyboard keys to be pressed and pop again.

[Photo: Apple]

The butterfly allowed for a keyboard that was 40% flatter than earlier keyboards. However these skinny keyboards had been vulnerable to failure (keys simply stopped working, which required the keyboard to get replaced or for somebody to only substitute their laptop computer completely). In consequence, Apple slowly reverted again to its previous scissors keyboard mechanisms in 2019 and 2020 whereas dealing with a class-action lawsuit.

However the new MacBook Pro does one thing else that’s necessary: It introduced again its bodily line of F keys (the “perform” keys which brighten your display or do different specialised duties), abandoning the Contact Bar. As Apple defined throughout the occasion, these keys “carry again the acquainted tactile really feel of bodily keys that customers love.” As we famous in 2016, when Apple first launched the Contact Bar, that was precisely the drawback with the design. The best benefit of laptops over tablets or telephones is their bodily buttons you can function with muscle reminiscence, and Apple swapped these out with a strip of buttons you had to take a look at to make use of.

Now, very like USB-C charging, the Contact Bar did try to resolve a higher design drawback: How do you customise a laptop computer’s interface for every app with the identical fluidity we’ve in our telephones? However backside line, Apple’s resolution simply wasn’t it. And albeit, I’m unsure that drawback was all that problematic to start with. Sure, it’s tough to study keyboard shortcuts. Nonetheless, it’s even trickier to grasp a keyboard when the keys are consistently shifting on you. Even when there is one thing helpful on the Contact Bar, my eyes are at all times on my pc display. I can’t consider a single app the place I believed, “Thank goodness I’ve this Contact Bar!” It was a technological resolution to a design drawback, which made it really feel remarkably un-Apple in the first place.

Apple recycling Apple

This isn’t the first time Apple has recycled its concepts. The iPhone 12 and 13 function a blocky, metal-wrapped chassis that’s principally a rehashed iPhone 4. Nonetheless, I see that call as seasonal, a technique to carry again an previous trend after the proper period of time has handed to make the previous really feel new once more.


With the MacBook Pro, Apple is going retro in the identify of consumer expertise. Apple is pruning again its personal design, discovering the essence of what made its laptops really easy to make use of and lovable—even when these concepts are greater than a decade previous.

[Photo: Apple]

We view some objects—sure chairs, sun shades, buildings, and automobiles—as traditional designs; issues which are so completely articulated that they want no additional repair. It’s uncommon that we are saying the identical about electronics, as a result of microprocessors shrink smaller and course of sooner yearly. Newer devices are typically smaller, lighter, and easily perform higher than previous ones on account of circuit board-level enhancements and ever-evolving code.

[Photo: Apple]

However maybe it’s time that we induct the MacBook Pro into the uncommon air of completely designed merchandise. Apple can maintain rushing up its processors, bettering its cameras, and swapping out supplies for greener alternate options. It might tweak the screen-to-case ratio, squeeze in a bigger battery, or regulate the curves of its silhouette 12 months to 12 months.

Nonetheless, at its core, this aluminum-bodied keyboard with a display, coupled with a useful energy cable, meets all of our basic ergonomic wants with restrained class. The brand new MacBook Pro is not making an attempt to do a factor that it can’t do completely. And in that manner, sure, it’s quite a bit like that previous MacBook Pro, the one you got someplace between 2008 and 2015, that many people nonetheless love.